The Loretta's War Sicklescalesrelatively equally with Strength,Dexterityand Intelligence, it is a goodWeaponfor Qualitybuilds whoalso incorporate Intelligence, and enjoy the defense and utility offered by Loretta's Slash. They are found around several of the Minor Erdtrees, acting as the trees protectors. : r/Eldenring by Best ash of war for guardian swordspear? If scaling was improved + had loretta's scorcery buff it would be a nice niche weapon.A few things to point out:It's faster than most halberds, feels really nice to 2H and it has longer range than the spear the guardians drop. First, swordspear has one of the highest (if not the highest) ARs for a dex weapon. Loretta's Slash is fine, but a bit underwhelming compared to many other ashes of war, damage-wise.My biggest disappointment is in its low poise-damage overall. 4) Increase it's Range and Height. I only wished that this can shoot out Sorceries like Loretta, or just increase the INT scaling and it's AoW damage. Vote Action role-playing game Role-playing video game Action game 0 comments Best Add a Comment Reddit, Inc. 2023. People that think that this needs a buff or that it should also cast spells also think that comet azur shouldn't be stationary while firing. lorreta's has the "niche" of being an ok choice for quality builds with a bit of int investment, making it an almost passable choice for an inefficient build. Whats everybody else rocking on this weapon? it fills a completely different need than guardian swordspear - this is a lorettas slash WA that primeraly scales with dex and upgrade level, while custom lorettas slash only scales with intelligence. Im just now wrapping up Caelid, and the only thing I really feel like Im missing is a good Ash of War. Reddit, Inc. 2023. So finally to summarize the **** edits before I delete them: No, it does not have worse damage than the Swordspear. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Are there other weapons with the same two-handed R1s? Offers exhilarating game play experience by featuring command-based combo attacks (such as " + attack" and " + attack") customized for each character, immersive hit feeling and diverse actions such as throwing weapons and using magic. Guardian's Swordspear. This weapon is absolutely beautiful and hits hard too, I would recommend having a shorter weapon to swap to in tight spaces like the catacomb areas. Enter up to 375 characters to add a description to your widget: Copy and paste the HTML below into your website to make the above widget appear. The range fo the R2 is insane and often catch players dodging sideways at the end of their roll. Seems a bit weird to have that bit in the description not reflect how it works mechanically, I really like the fast swinging r1, I feel the ash of war is kind of lazy, its winged scythe but with magic and no special effect, feels a bit lazy, though I do like it gets a blue imbuement with it, the scaling damage is disappointing though, this was the weapon that made me want to switch from faith to try out int but it doesnt seem worth it and I cant find a very good weapon to pair with it, power stancing is way too slow feeling, a greatsword or long sword is too stiff and slow feeling, a shield cant block as well attack even though its a polearm, and a faster curved sword or dagger kind of loses what makes them special, their flowing quick attacks because left hand makes them lose most of their moveset, so I dont really know what I can do, uh loretta thats not a sickle, its a glaive, Trying this out on haligtree knights compared to other halberds I found out it doesn't do enough poise dmg to interrupt their attacks like other halberds do. But as every souls games : fashion and skill > meta, I'm remaking my post after further analysis of the weapon End Game & Post Game at +10 - comparing to the sadly superior Guardian's Swordspear:LORETTA'S WAR SICKLE OBJECTIVELY NEEDS A BUFF:It has worse scaling, fixed weapon art, higher weight and lower damage than a random drop weapon.This weapon needs the following FIXES and BUFFS:1) BOOST Loretta Sorceries! The weapon art is also fantastic. my main gripe is that the gem on the bottom end is red. I LOVE this Weapon but got 3 Major Gripes with it:1) WHY DOESN'T IT BOOSTS LORRETA SORCERIES? It's biggest weakness is honestly that you can't get frost damage or set up any other synergistic status / proc stuff. Put it on the skinnier dex-er halberds like the pest glaive and the vulgar shotel! Some people mention its horizontal reach being good for fliers, but the Cross Naginata similarly starts with a vertical downwards slash with great upper reach, is much lighter and comes with innate bleed buildup. var sc_security="fa126e88"; See pages that link to and include this page. It's not a straight INT weapon. Note: Also see Toxic Spirit Sword. Sword of the Guardian is an old style Beat'em up game. Weighs a bit less too. The weapon balancing in Elden Ring is very poor, and this weapon is unfortunately another victim of it. Cookie Notice The damage is disappointing, and might be amongst the weakest halberds. Alternatively, L2 could have just cast a Sorcery and simply make Loretta's Slash the R2 (That way you could do mounted Loretta's Slash like Loretta does), Correct me if I'm wrong but im 90% sure this has Freide's Great Scythe moveset, even the AoW is similar to Friede's Light weapon art. 40 STR and 40 DEX two handed gives almost the same damage as 80 DEX and it allows for other STR weapons to be tossed into your use as well. Otherwise, Swordspear has the build variety, lower stat requirements, customizable ashes, etc.Even on a 20/50/50 Str/Dex/Int build that Loretta is specifically built for, the Swordspear hits nearly the same AR on Magic infusion (729 vs 736). It just doesn't do enough for how much FP it costs, and especially how much time is taken to execute the weapon art. At best. So if she replaced the glintstone in her glaive with unalloyed gold, wouldn't that by extension remove all magic damage and add holy damage? I love this weapon but this almost feels bugged. This is a weapon for level 300 characters with 99 INT, 99 DEX, and 99 STR)(I don't even know why anyone would think this is a good argument. The odd thing is despite the Str requirement being higher than Dec, I'm still seeing slightly more AR when putting points into Dex over Str passed 20.For example, at 40STR, 20 DEX, and 55INT, AR was 650 at +9, while with 20STR and 40 Dex it's 660.Very minor difference, but still. 27 comments Best Add a Comment El__Jengibre :hollowed2: 1 yr. ago You farm it off the guardians that pop up around the minor trees. My question is for other Guardian Swordspear users: what ashes of war do you prefer? Scan this QR code to download the app now. 3 x Poor scaling is just meh. With it, you can easily outspace and punish running R1 spammer (spear, rapier, and many other thrusting attacks) with your own running attack. and one blood. Oh boy another really sexy looking weapon that turns out to be very underwhelming and mediocre, despite being dropped by a late game boss in a hidden difficult secret area. This defaults to your Review Score Setting. Guardian Sword Highlight is the unique gameplay that allows the players to customize the puzzles by themselves. LS also seems to increase status damage, so that works really well - but again, that's just a different build. Scaling should have been: B - C - A or C - B - A (STR - DEX - INT). This upgrade can be enchanted withMagic or boosted withConsumables. Any other halberds with the same mooveset ? Elden Ring Weapon Showcase: Guardian's Swordspear - YouTube I think the intent for this weapon was to be another Cleanrot type weapon with higher physical stats than faith, but in this case, intelligence replaces the faith. Why doesn't it get buffed by Raptor's Black Feather Armor or Claw Talisman??? As much as I like this weapon, my dissapointment when I realized I couldn't cast sorceries through it like Loretta was immense. It mainly scales off of Int (regardless of what it says, when I try putting points into Dex or Str the damage does not go up) but does primarily physical damage, which makes it really nice into enemies resistant to magic. A cool looking weapon with a fun moveset & anime AF Weapon Skill, brought down by its awkward scaling. My favorite looking halberd ruined by the dumbest moveset, Honestly kind of wish this was a hybrid staff weapon. It's meant to be a weapon for a battlemage (like Loretta herself), but emphasizing a Quality/Int spread, with bigger emphasis on the Quality side than the Int side. My goal is to go primarily dex with some arcane. you'll legit get more damage magic infusing a guardian swordspear with lorettas slash than using this. So if your build tends towards that, you might like this weapon. why is it red?? Any halberd players will already be aware of this. so disappointing, Very nice looking, good magic damage on the AoW, and an actually good moveset. Privacy Policy. Append content without editing the whole page source. Shares some similar design details with the dragon halberd. All rights reserved. Espaol - Latinoamrica (Spanish - Latin America). suggestions on how to build around guardian swordspear (s) Go here: Want more guardian;s swordspear action? Currently, I'm powerstancing two of them- one keen(which gets A scaling!) Guardian's Swordspear | Elden Ring Wiki - Fextralife By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Banished Knight's Halberd has better scaling when infused with loretta's slash and you get frost damage to boot. Very slow and modest damage for a strong attack. Sadly, at meta level, Swordspear just plain better in everything except range and looks. As no item in the game boosts Loretta spells, not even her set! Notify administrators if there is objectionable content in this page. its a shame. Elden Ring, Malenia, Solo, No damage, Guardian's Swordspear.Good weapon. Guardian is a Humanoid Enemy in Elden Ring. I never fully charge it ; never worth it.Running R1 & R2 : Your bread and butter. It would have been cool if you could cast magic with it.. It has similar super armor qualities but LS is getting buffed because you guys are dropping the ball on recognizing a decent weapon just because there's an early game damage difference. 3) As others mentioned, being able to cast spells from it would've been nice. Dissapointing. DISCORD- https://discord.com/invite/pZn2nMPRneTWITCH- https://www.twitch.tv/youwy_BUILD OVERVIEW 0:00DAM. Sign in to add this item to your wishlist, follow it, or mark it as ignored. Hate the moveset, otherwise amazing weapon. Why did they not make this weapon a staff that could hit you? Wish we could get the version before the glintstone was removed, the gold looks kinda weird if you ask me. Ive been in love with this thing since I picked it up in the early game. whats with all the super cool weapons with completely ordinary ashes of war? PSA: Guardian Swordspear is INSANE : r/Eldenring - Reddit Kinda lame considering Loretta herself does so in both encounters against her. View/set parent page (used for creating breadcrumbs and structured layout). Can this really be enchanted? you're honestly going to get better damage out of attaching Loretta's Slash to pretty much any halberd if you want to use the WA with good returns on INT scaling. Thought this would be immolation tinder 2 but was disappointed, cool moveset though. I do agree the Ash of War could use a bit of a buff in damage, but otherwise its really solid. When I first fought the ghost version I was absolutely mesmerized by how well animated and badass the attack to spell casting animations for her were. Click here to toggle editing of individual sections of the page (if possible). It was developed by FromSoft and published by Bandai Namco. The Guardians are mainly found near the small Erdtree in all areas. My favorite looking weapon with a fun moveset, but I'm afraid the Guardian Swordspear is better, whether you intend to play INT/DEX or Quality. It's a very interesting weapon. The damage (755 AR on 25STR, 59DEX, 43INT) is pretty good, the moveset is great (Running poke, long range on R1s) and it's really fashionable. Its only benefit over the Guardian Swordspear is reach. It's 3.5 lbs heavier and only takes 3 FP less to cast. Loretta's War Sickle | Elden Ring Wiki - Fextralife Unless otherwise stated, the content of this page is licensed under. Can't say much more ; I'm not a big fan of the "crouch" tactic ; not intuitive to me yet.Finally, Loretta's Slash : It is an underwhelming and very inconsistent attack. This is the subreddit for the Elden Ring gaming community. Its heavier, not particularly more damaging, same moveset and characteristics Loretta's Slash is where the weapon really is let down. You can re-orient partially the strike mid-air, but the tracking is still poor. I hope the a Developers Buff this to at least Boost Loretta Spells and Buff Scaling! Shares the same moveset as the Guardian's Swordspear while providing more range, but poorer scaling for builds purely focused on Intelligence. Reddit, Inc. 2023. I've been in love with this thing since I picked it up in the early game. In my opinion : Fine when exploring, weak when fighting bosses. Tarnished Golden Sunflower. I'm going to power-stance 2 of these. Guardian's Swordspear - How To Get & Stats - GameWith Oh well, at least the moveset on its own is fun and actually pretty glaive like for once. wish the weapon art was a slightly unique version of the normal one, maybe granting a glintblade phalanx on a successful hit or something. not to mention that the WA in practice is janky as hell, with your blade passing through people as they wail on you while youre still floating. the running R1 is a rollcatching machine ; it's not rare to chain 3 or 4 of them while your foe spam away the dodge button. Although it is highly situational, it's decent for roll-catching panicking players, but most importantly it is quite good against agressive players coming straight toward you for a running or standard R1. Rich story of the Modern War with its own philosophy. Yes, that is how it should be. For my str/int build Ive gone with the rosus axe and the combo is a lot of fun. Second, Thunderbolt scales with base/dex damage and barely uses any FP Unbuffed attack - 670+ a hit Lightning armament buff - 800+ Thunderbolt - 885 per strike Intricately crafted silver war sickle wielded by Loretta, Knight of the Haligtree. Guardian Swordspear Affinity/Ash of War Just realized how much the Guardian Swordspear slaps, and I've noticed a couple discussions about it. If there's any DS3 players reading, this R1 chain feels highly similar to Hollowslayer / Drakeblood GS. You will experience certain situations, those, that could have happened with our parents, children or even a neighbours on just any other war.